PAMED Fighting Package of Tort Reform Bills

A handful of bills have been introduced in the state House of Representatives that would loosen tort laws in favor of trial lawyers, increase medical liability payouts, and drive up the cost of liability insurance.  

The Pennsylvania Medical Society strongly opposes these bills and is coordinating efforts to fight the legislation with other health care and business organizations.  

The bills were introduced at the request of the state’s trial bar, which now calls itself the Pennsylvania Association for Justice. They are: 

  • House Bill 2123, introduced by Rep. Paul Drucker (D-Chester, Montgomery), would invalidate pre-treatment arbitration agreements, eliminating a valuable tool for more efficiently resolving disputes with lower costs and less acrimony. The bill is unnecessary since courts already have the right to invalidate any arbitration agreement that is unfair or made under duress.
  • House Bill 1444, introduced by Rep. Matthew Bradford (D-Montgomery), would allow trial lawyers to quantify damages for pain and suffering, something that should be left up to juries. Mixing quantified non-evidential, non-economic requests with hard evidence of economic damages will confuse juries and drive up awards.
  • House Bill 1095, introduced by Rep. Jesse White (D-Allegheny), and House Bill 2202, introduced by Rep. Michael Gerber (D-Montgomery), would expand the types of damages that can be recovered and the persons who can sue to recover them. These bills would significantly increase liability insurance costs, while making Pennsylvania one of the most litigation-friendly states in the country.

Voting mostly on party lines, the House Judiciary Committee on Jan. 26, 2010, approved the bills and sent them on to the full House. 

Add Your Comments


The Pennsylvania Medical Society encourages lively debate, but please behave courteously and responsibly. Comments that include profanity, personal attacks (including language that could potentially identify an individual), or any other inappropriate, offensive, or illegal material will be removed. For more information, please see our Terms of Use.

Display name as (optional):

Comments (max 2000 characters):




Comments: 4


You need to set up a system to forward emails to our legislators to urge a vote against these bills. Make it easier for your membership to get involved.

mike rusli, MD at 3/30/2010 11:19:29 PM


After theft of the MCARE funds and the comparable hospital derived funds to "balance the budget" now comes the House again...trying to further destroy the physicians of this state.Where will it all end?? asocialized system?? The trial attorneys willhave to sue themselves and their greedy legislators.

anonymous at 3/25/2010 10:00:39 PM


Keep fighting against the trial bar's shameless attempts to line their pockets while destroying health care in PA! No surprise that all of these shameless bill's sponsors had a (D) after their names either, as usual, the (D)'s are clearly in the pockets of the trial lawyers!

anonymous at 3/25/2010 11:59:34 AM


The state of tort reform is bad enough in Penssylvania and the changes proposed in the above mentioned bills would make it even worse.It is already difficult to bring doctors to Pa and many doctors continue to leave pPa.

bruce stark at 3/18/2010 3:44:43 PM

Last Updated: 3/4/2010
From: 
Email:  
To: 
Email:  
Subject: 
Message: